Conservation of Fish Stocks and Management of Pinnipeds Act

Bill defeated

C-251
February 9, 2022 (3 years ago)
Canadian Federal
Clifford Small
Conservative
House of Commons
Third reading
1 Votes
Full Title: An Act respecting the development of a federal framework on the conservation of fish stocks and management of pinnipeds
Climate and Environment
Economics
Social Issues
Foreign Affairs

Summary

The Conservation of Fish Stocks and Management of Pinnipeds Act aims to create a federal framework for conserving fish stocks and managing seal populations. It emphasizes collaboration with provincial governments, Indigenous groups, and stakeholders to address various interests in marine ecology.

What it means for you

Coastal and rural communities, especially those involved in fishing and seal product sales, could benefit from job creation and economic opportunities. However, taxpayers might bear the financial burden due to the costs of implementing the new measures. Animal rights advocates may also feel affected by the proposed measures for managing pinniped populations.

Expenses

Taxpayer expenses could rise due to the cost involved in conducting annual pinniped censuses and developing new regulatory measures. There is uncertainty around funding sources and the overall budget needed for successful implementation. Additionally, promoting pinniped products could entail marketing costs, and international trade barriers could further complicate economic outcomes.

Proponents view

Supporters advocate for the Act as a proactive measure for ecological sustainability, asserting that regulating pinniped populations is essential for maintaining fish stocks critical to the fishing industry. They emphasize that healthy marine ecosystems benefit both the environment and local economies, particularly for Indigenous, coastal, and rural communities through job creation and new markets for pinniped products.

Opponents view

Critics are concerned about the financial implications of the Act, arguing the costs might outweigh its benefits. They suggest that focusing too heavily on pinniped management could detract from addressing other important environmental issues. Furthermore, they express ethical concerns regarding animal rights and worry that aggressive management tactics might disrupt natural balances in marine ecosystems. There's also apprehension about possible trade barriers impacting local economies and international relations.

Original Bill

Votes

Vote 151

That the bill be now read a second time and referred to the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans.

For (45%)
Against (53%)
Paired (2%)