Constitution Act, 2022 (representation of Quebec)

Bill defeated

C-246
February 8, 2022 (3 years ago)
Canadian Federal
Martin Champoux
Bloc Québécois
House of Commons
Third reading
1 Votes
Full Title: An Act to amend the Constitution Act, 1867 (representation in the House of Commons)
Social Issues
Infrastructure

Summary

The Constitution Act, 2022 proposes an amendment to ensure Quebec holds at least 25% of the seats in the House of Commons, potentially increasing the number of MPs from Quebec in response to population changes.

What it means for you

This change primarily impacts residents of Quebec by potentially amplifying their voice in federal politics. Other provinces, especially those with smaller populations, may feel sidelined or less represented. Citizens across Canada might worry about how this could affect policy decisions and resource allocation.

Expenses

Increasing the number of MPs from Quebec will likely lead to higher government spending on salaries, office resources, and administrative costs associated with more representatives. While proponents argue that these costs are a necessary investment for better representation, opponents caution that larger government expenses could burden taxpayers and lead to less efficient governance.

Proponents view

Supporters argue that this amendment is vital to acknowledge Quebec's unique cultural and linguistic identity. They believe it will correct historical representation imbalances and promote fair political power, enhancing Quebec's influence in federal matters, which can lead to better advocacy for their specific needs and interests.

Opponents view

Critics warn that adding more members may not improve governance but could instead lead to higher costs and complexity in the legislative process. They raise concerns about regionalism, suggesting this could alienate other provinces and disrupt national unity. Additionally, they argue that this focus on Quebec could come at the price of diminishing representation for smaller provinces, undermining equitable political representation across Canada.

Original Bill

Votes

Vote 140

That the bill be now read a second time and referred to the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs.

For (16%)
Against (81%)
Paired (4%)