Maximum Security Matters

Bill defeated

C-351
September 18, 2023 (a year ago)
Canadian Federal
Bernard Généreux
Conservative
House of Commons
Third reading
1 Votes
Full Title: An Act to amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (maximum security offenders)
Criminal Justice
Economics
Social Issues

Summary

The proposed amendments to the Corrections and Conditional Release Act aim to classify certain high-risk inmates, particularly dangerous offenders and those convicted of multiple first-degree murders, as maximum security prisoners. This means they will be confined in designated maximum security facilities.

What it means for you

Groups that may be impacted include victims of crime and the general public, who may feel safer knowing that dangerous offenders are kept in maximum security. However, current inmates who may be classified under this law could face harsher confinement. Additionally, taxpayers could feel the effects through changes in budget priorities or increased taxes.

Expenses

Operating maximum security facilities is generally more expensive due to the need for increased staffing, enhanced security measures, and specialized training for personnel. This could lead to significant budget strains on correctional facilities, particularly in regions that already have limited resources. Such expenses may ultimately be passed down to taxpayers, contributing to higher public spending.

Proponents view

Supporters argue that the amendments are necessary for public safety, claiming that confining the most dangerous criminals in maximum security reduces the likelihood of future crimes and improves inmate management. They also believe that by better allocating resources, fewer incidents in prisons can lead to lower overall costs in the long run.

Opponents view

Critics contend that the financial implications of operating maximum security facilities could lead local governments to divert funds from other critical areas, such as education or social services. They worry that classifying inmates without considering individual behavior may result in unjust punishment and hinder efforts at rehabilitation. There is also a concern that overcrowding in maximum security facilities could emerge, creating other safety and management issues.

Original Bill

Votes

Vote 745

That the bill be now read a second time and referred to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security.

For (36%)
Against (63%)
Paired (1%)