Harsher Penalties for Attacks on First Responders

Summary#

This bill changes Canada’s Criminal Code to add new protections for first responders. It makes the murder of a first responder on duty automatically first-degree murder. It raises the maximum sentence for aggravated assault when the victim is a first responder or another person listed in section 231(4). It also updates several laws so these offences trigger stronger investigation and sentencing tools.

• Makes killing a first responder on duty first-degree murder (s.231(4) amendment).
• Creates a specific offence of assaulting a first responder and aligns related offences (ss.270, 270.01, 270.02).
• Raises the maximum penalty for aggravated assault against first responders and other listed persons to up to 20 years (s.268(2) as amended).
• Allows wiretap warrants for serious assaults on first responders (s.183 offences list).
• Makes these offences eligible for DNA orders and dangerous offender applications (s.487.04; s.752).
• Classifies these offences as serious for parole and for corporate director eligibility (Corrections and Conditional Release Act Schedule I; Canada Business Corporations Act schedule).

What it means for you#

• Households

  • If a first responder is killed while on duty, the charge is treated as first-degree murder. First-degree murder is the most serious homicide category in Canada (s.231(4) amendment).
  • Aggravated assault against a first responder or other listed person can carry a higher maximum sentence of up to 20 years (s.268(2) as amended).

• First responders (including volunteers)

  • The law defines “first responder” to include employees and formally engaged volunteers who are first on scene to provide medical help or firefighting, including EMTs, paramedics, and firefighters (s.2 definition).
  • Assaulting you while you are doing your job is a specific offence, with higher penalties when a weapon is used or bodily harm is caused, or when it is aggravated (ss.270, 270.01, 270.02).
  • Serious assaults against you are added to the list of offences for which police may seek a wiretap warrant (s.183).
  • These assaults are listed as serious violent crimes for parole purposes (Corrections and Conditional Release Act, Schedule I).

• Accused persons and defendants

  • If convicted of assaulting a first responder under ss.270, 270.01, or 270.02, the court may order you to provide a DNA sample because the offences are “primary” or “secondary designated offences” (s.487.04).
  • A conviction for these offences can be used by prosecutors to seek a dangerous offender or long-term offender application because they are “designated offences” (s.752).
  • For aggravated assault where the victim is a person described in s.231(4), the maximum sentence increases to up to 20 years (s.268(2) as amended). The bill does not change the general maximum for other aggravated assaults in its text.

• Businesses and non-profits

  • People convicted of assaulting a first responder under ss.270, 270.01, or 270.02 face added barriers to serving as a director or officer under the Canada Business Corporations Act schedule (CBCA schedule amendment).

• Police and prosecutors

  • You may seek wiretap authorizations for assaults on first responders that involve a weapon, cause bodily harm, or are aggravated (s.183; ss.270.01, 270.02).
  • DNA orders are available or presumptively required for these offences (s.487.04).
  • The amendments align charging and sentencing options with existing protections for peace officers (multiple sections cited above).
  • Effective date: Data unavailable in the provided text.

Expenses#

Estimated net cost: Data unavailable.

• The bill contains no direct spending, taxes, or fees (bill text).
• It changes criminal classifications and penalties. Any added costs to policing, courts, or corrections are not quantified. Data unavailable.
• No official fiscal note identified. Data unavailable.

Proponents' View#

• Stronger protection for first responders: Making murder of an on-duty first responder first-degree signals clear, uniform treatment for the most serious cases (s.231(4) amendment).
• Harsher penalties deter assaults: Raising the maximum for aggravated assault to up to 20 years when the victim is a first responder or other listed person is intended to deter violent attacks (s.268(2) as amended). Assumes deterrence from higher maximums.
• Better investigative tools: Adding serious assaults on first responders to the wiretap list helps investigate organized or repeat offenders who target responders (s.183; ss.270.01, 270.02). Assumes judicially authorized wiretaps will aid case clearance.
• Faster identification of offenders: DNA order eligibility supports solving and linking cases involving assaults on first responders (s.487.04). Assumes DNA collection improves investigations.
• Consistency across statutes: Updates to the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, the CBCA, and dangerous offender provisions align treatment of these offences with those against peace officers (Corrections and Conditional Release Act Schedule I; CBCA schedule; s.752).

Opponents' View#

• Reduced flexibility in homicide cases: Automatic first-degree classification for killing a first responder on duty may remove discretion to reflect varied facts and intent, potentially increasing trial complexity (s.231(4) amendment). Assumes some cases would otherwise be second-degree.
• Broad scope of “first responder”: The definition includes formally engaged volunteers, which could expand severe penalties beyond professionals and create disputes over status at the time of the incident (s.2 definition).
• Expanded surveillance powers: Allowing wiretaps for assaults that involve a weapon or bodily harm may widen the use of intrusive tools relative to the underlying conduct (s.183; s.270.01). Judicial safeguards still apply.
• Higher incarceration and system costs: Longer maximums and more offences in Schedule I and dangerous offender lists may increase prison time and parole supervision costs. No cost estimates are provided (Corrections and Conditional Release Act Schedule I; s.752). Data unavailable.
• Collateral consequences: Adding these offences to DNA databank and corporate director disqualification lists has lasting effects on privacy and employment after sentence completion (s.487.04; CBCA schedule). Assumes convictions will lead to orders and disqualifications in practice.