New Institute Boosts First Nations Infrastructure Financing

Summary#

This bill updates the First Nations Fiscal Management Act. It expands the roles of two national First Nations institutions and creates a new First Nations Infrastructure Institute. It also lets participating First Nations make and enforce laws about services on reserve, and it modernizes borrowing rules that use local and other revenues.

• Creates the First Nations Infrastructure Institute to help plan, build, finance, and manage infrastructure; it can set standards and certify projects (Part 5.2, ss. 101–116, 113.4–113.9).
• Lets First Nations make and enforce laws about services on reserve, including water, wastewater, waste, roads, energy, and telecoms (Part 5.1, s. 96–99).
• Broadens “other revenues” that can secure loans and sets conditions for loans secured by those revenues (s. 2(1); s. 74(b); s. 79(2)).
• Combines debt reserve funds and sets a standard 5% holdback on loans, with power to lower it to as little as 1% if it will not harm the Authority’s credit rating (s. 84(2)–(2.1)).
• Expands the oversight powers of the First Nations Financial Management Board to impose co‑management or third‑party management over local and other revenues if there is risk of default (ss. 51–53.1).
• Extends eligibility so certain Indigenous groups and not-for-profit service organizations can access pooled borrowing by regulation (ss. 2(2.1), 50.1, 141, 141.1).

What it means for you#

• Households and service users on reserve

  • Your First Nation may pass service laws for water, wastewater, drainage, waste, animal control, recreation, transport, telecoms, and energy (s. 96(1)).
  • Laws can be enforced by court orders, cost recovery, liens or legal hypothecs on interests in reserve lands, and service disconnections (s. 96(1)(c)(iii)–(v), (3)–(4)).
  • These laws take effect after publication in the First Nations Gazette or on a later date named in the law (s. 98).
  • If your First Nation uses the new Infrastructure Institute, some projects may be reviewed against standards and receive a compliance certificate (s. 113.5).

• First Nations governments and administrators

  • You must have a financial administration law approved by the First Nations Financial Management Board before making borrowing laws (s. 4).
  • You may make laws to borrow using local revenues and, now, “other revenues,” and you may delegate certain powers (ss. 5(1)(d), 8.1(1)).
  • “Other revenues” now includes items like leases, royalties, business income, transfers from provinces/municipalities, and some federal transfers if agreements allow (s. 2(1), definition of other revenues).
  • To borrow using other revenues, you must have: a borrowing law; a financial performance certificate from the Board; and a secured revenues trust account managed by a third party that pays the Authority first (s. 79(2)(a)–(e)).
  • The Board can impose co‑management or third‑party management over local or other revenues if there is risk of default or missed obligations; this can include ordering co‑signing of cheques or taking over revenue management (ss. 51–53.1).
  • You can use the First Nations Infrastructure Institute for planning, procurement, project management, asset management, and standards/certification (ss. 113.4–113.8).
  • Data functions expand: institutions may collect and publish statistical data but must avoid identifying individuals or communities without consent or where already public (ss. 35, 55 [Data], 113.9).

• Borrowing members (First Nations and eligible Indigenous entities)

  • Loans secured by property tax revenues: the First Nations Tax Commission must approve the borrowing law (s. 79(1)).
  • Loans secured by other revenues: meet the conditions in s. 79(2), including depositing pledged revenues into a trust or intermediate account and giving the Authority first claim on payments (s. 79(2)(d)–(e)).
  • The Authority withholds 5% of each loan for the debt reserve fund; the board may lower this to no less than 1% by resolution (s. 84(2), (2.1)).
  • If the debt reserve fund drops, you may be required to replenish it without delay, depending on the shortfall (s. 84(5)).
  • If insolvent, the Authority has priority over other creditors for debts arising after your first loan’s initial disbursement (s. 78(1)).
  • You may leave the borrowing pool only with the consent of all other borrowing members (s. 77).

• On‑reserve taxpayers and businesses

  • The First Nations Tax Commission’s mandate expands to support local revenue systems, taxpayer relations, and dispute support services (s. 29(a)–(m)).
  • Local revenue laws and service laws can be enforced in court; non‑compliance can lead to cost recovery and, for services, liens or service cut‑offs (ss. 5(5)–(6.1); 96(1)(c)).

• Indigenous not‑for‑profits and other Indigenous groups

  • Certain Indigenous groups and not‑for‑profit service organizations may be made eligible by regulation to receive services and participate in pooled borrowing (ss. 2(2.1), 50.1, 141, 141.1).

• Timing

  • Many sections come into force on dates set by the Governor in Council; service laws and standards take effect upon publication or as stated (Coming into Force; s. 98; s. 113.8(4)).

Expenses#

• Estimated net cost: Data unavailable.

• Fiscal information

  • Governor General’s recommendation signals that appropriations are authorized, but the bill sets no dollar amounts (Recommendation; Summary).
  • The new Institute may charge fees for services set by regulation (s. 116).
  • “No appropriation” clause bars using appropriations to pay third‑party claims against institutions; it does not state operating budgets (s. 135).
  • Debt reserve fund mechanics do not affect the federal budget; they are internal to the borrowing Authority (s. 84).

• Appropriations or mandates specified in the bill

  • Establishes a new federal institution (First Nations Infrastructure Institute) and expands mandates of existing institutions (Parts 5.1, 5.2; s. 29; s. 49). Operating cost amounts: Data unavailable.
  • Consequential inclusion of the Institute under the Access to Information Act and the Privacy Act may have minor administrative costs: Data unavailable.

Proponents' View#

• Improves access to capital by allowing loans secured by broader “other revenues” for economic and social development, including housing, utilities, land, and equipment (s. 74(b); s. 2(1), other revenues; s. 79(2)).
• Reduces borrowing costs and frees funds for projects by combining debt reserve funds and allowing the holdback to drop from 5% to as low as 1% if credit quality is maintained (s. 84(2)–(2.1)).
• Speeds and strengthens infrastructure delivery through a dedicated Institute that sets standards, supports procurement and asset management, and can certify projects (Part 5.2; s. 113.4–113.8).
• Enhances local governance by letting First Nations make and enforce service laws on reserve to protect health, safety, and infrastructure assets (Part 5.1, s. 96).
• Expands eligibility so more Indigenous entities can access pooled borrowing and capacity services, which can spread risk and lower rates (ss. 2(2.1), 50.1, 141, 141.1).
• Increases transparency and evidence by authorizing institutions to collect and publish non‑identifying data on fiscal and infrastructure matters (s. 35; s. 55 [Data]; s. 113.9).

Opponents' View#

• Expands intervention powers that may limit local autonomy: the Board can impose co‑management or third‑party management over “other revenues,” including revenues not pledged as loan security, if it sees risk of default (ss. 52.1, 53.1).
• Creates strong enforcement tools under service laws, including liens on interests in reserve lands and service disconnections, which could affect vulnerable households or small businesses (s. 96(1)(c)(iv)–(v)).
• Limits exit and increases creditor priority: a borrowing member can leave only with consent of all others, and the Authority has priority over other creditors in insolvency for certain debts (s. 77; s. 78(1)).
• Debt reserve fund replenishment calls may create sudden payment obligations for borrowing members if the fund is drawn down by 50% or more, or even at lower thresholds (s. 84(5)).
• New data collection powers, even with de‑identification rules, may raise privacy concerns within small communities where data could indirectly identify parties (s. 35; s. 55 [Data]; s. 113.9).
• Fiscal impact is unclear: the bill creates a new federal institute and expands mandates but provides no public cost estimates or timelines for funding, creating budgeting uncertainty (Recommendation; Coming into Force).